Enabling more participation

Education and participation: Improving the utilization of the BuT package

(Photo © MKJFGFI NRW / S. Schürmann)

Josefine Paul, Minister for Family Affairs in North Rhine-Westphalia:

"Poverty is the greatest risk to the future for children and young people. We must therefore ensure that all young people in North Rhine-Westphalia have the opportunity to develop their potential and participate. This is why it is so important that the funds earmarked for strengthening the participation of children and young people affected or at risk of poverty and enabling them to grow up in a good and healthy environment also reach them. Together with local stakeholders, it is therefore my goal to further increase the uptake of education and participation benefits."

Factors influencing the use of social and family benefits

The use of social and family benefits depends on a variety of factors. The relevant research literature shows that the individual resources of families and the design of benefits are of central importance:

Individual resources

Eligibility and knowledge about how it works ➔ Basic prerequisite for claiming
Experience with other social benefits
Information behavior
Socioeconomic situation of the family: living situation and income situation
Socidemographics: level of education. Language skills and gender

Design of benefits

Complexity (e.g. application process)
Expense for claimants
Address by authorities when new benefit claims arise
Reliability of the benefit (e.g. amount. Risk of repayments. Adjustments over time. automated payment)
Signal effect and image of the benefit

In order to identify the specific levers for improving the use of education and participation services in North Rhine-Westphalia and to develop tailor-made measures, the Ministry of Family Affairs is proceeding in several steps:

Um die konkreten Stellschrauben für eine verbesserte Inanspruchnahme der Bildungs- und Teilhabeleistungen in Nordrhein-Westfalen zu identifizieren und passgenaue Maßnahmen zu entwickeln, geht das Familienministerium in mehreren Schritten vor:

Dialog process

Two workshops with municipal stakeholders were held to provide an initial exchange of experiences on administrative practice in the implementation of the education and participation package and to identify and develop examples of good practice.

Under the title "Enabling participation - success factors for improved use of the BuT package in NRW", the Ministry of Family Affairs launched an exchange with experts from public administration and other organizations on 28 November 2024 in Düsseldorf and 29 November 2024 in Dortmund. The expert input from Prognos AG and the two workshop documentations are available for download in the sidebar.

Enabling participation: Impressions from November 28, 2024

Survey of specialists

An online survey on the education and participation package in spring 2025 aimed to record the assessments and structures of BuT at local authority level and to obtain assessments of obstacles and beneficial access factors as well as information on the local design. In addition, the survey was used as an opportunity to survey and systematically collect existing examples of good practice.

The survey asked managers from institutions that support families in applying for BuT and/or are responsible for approving BuT benefits.

One result of the nationwide online survey is that the biggest hurdles for families are often language barriers, a lack of information about the benefits and the sometimes time-consuming application process. Authorities also cite incomplete applications, a lack of resources and insufficient digitalization as key problems. The survey also makes it clear that many municipalities already have close cooperation structures, for example with schools, daycare facilities or school social work. At the same time, there is a considerable backlog in the digital application process. Only 20 percent of local authorities offer a digital application.

All results of the survey are available for download in the sidebar.

Publicity material

Workshops and the survey have shown that there is a lack of suitable publicity material locally - particularly multilingual information and information in plain language.

The Familienportal.NRW provides multilingual information material for families and professionals. Posters, postcards and information flyers in German, English, Italian, Polish, Romanian, Turkish and plain language can be ordered free of charge or downloaded digitally.

Topic-oriented workshops

In order to deepen and implement the findings from the workshops already held and the survey, further practice-oriented workshops on various topics are planned for fall 2025. These are aimed at professionals in local authorities and other departments involved with BuT (e.g. from school social work or family centers).